Mulberry Street Pizza: Authentic NY Style Pizza & Italian Cuisine in Manchester, CT

If you havent eaten here already, you definitely need to. The pizza was amazing. Got a basic large cheese pizza. The crust? Immaculate even down to the thinnest parts it didn’t get soggy or fall apart at all, a nice crisp bit every time. The sauce? Flavorful as all hell, but not too over powering. The cheese? Definitely not for everybody, I know people don’t like the mozz/Parm combo, which I normally don’t. This place might have changed my mind though. Only complaint I had was it took an hour for my order to be ready. The pizza and the staff are amazing! This place has a new customer.

Stopped in for lunch with my wife. Taken in by the atmosphere immediately. Sat down, cool surroundings. Onion app was out of this world. Then we ordered a small Twister pizza....OMG....over the top flavorful. Beautiful thni crust. Ill be recommending this to ALL of my friends. EXCELLENT!!!

Up from Myrtle Beach, had to stop at Mulberry as usual. Another great pizza and drinks!! Secret garden with bacon added. Also had the peanut butter ginger wings but they were gone before I could take a pic. We've been gone 8 years but still stop by every time we visit.

Mulberry street The Slice Mob rolled into Mulberry Street Pizza in Manchester today, and yeah, we took the place over. Fourteen hungry Mobsters… twenty pizzas. Twenty. Even I had a “Yikes!” moment, and I don’t scare easily when it comes to carbs. And let me tell you: every single pie slapped. Mulberry runs a thin crust cooked on a stone deck, with dough that’s cold-fermented for three days, coated in oil, and then stretched. The result? A beautiful, crisp undercarriage with just the right chew. The Pies I Tried Goodfellas This was a masterpiece: crushed tomatoes, Romano, fresh mozzarella, garlic, basil, olive oil. The sauce was sweet but not too sweet. The mozzarella and the salty pop of Romano kept everything in perfect balance. And the chunky tomatoes added this little burst of texture that made each bite hit different. Just phenomenal. The Titanic Enough meat to actually sink something. Pepperoni, sausage, bacon, meatballs, plus tomato sauce, mozzarella, and Romano. Salty? Yes. Overwhelming? Not even close. The mozzarella and sauce rounded it all out, turning what could’ve been a heavy pie into a flavor bomb I’d order again with zero hesitation. Bonus Slice: The Italian Job (White Pizza) Lemon crème sauce, prosciutto, caramelized onions, basil, Romano. OMG. This thing stole the show. Subtle lemon, sweet onions, salty prosciutto, all playing the same melody. Absolute star of the day. I love lemon on anything, and this one delivered. The Spot & The Vibe Mulberry Street has been a local favorite for 20 years, and after today, I get it. The place has that warm, classic pizza-joint energy, community photos, coppery lighting, booths full of people who’ve clearly been coming for years. And the service? White glove. Serving our table alone is a workout, but they managed us plus a packed dining room without missing a beat. You can’t teach that kind of rhythm. The Mob Grows We welcomed three new Slice Mob members today, love seeing the family expand. New friends, great laughs, ridiculous amounts of incredible pizza… honestly, this stuff brings a tear to my eye. Mulberry Street Pizza? 100% Slice Mob Approved. Get there.

Love the high ceilings, the talkative, friendly staff, and the absolutely amazing pizza. Maybe more of a mix of New Haven and New York style, but not too greasy, the meat isn't dry, and the flavor combos are on point.

I lived in Manchester all my life and never came to Mulberry until tonight. The old downtown building is always charming with the plaster ceiling and old brass light fixtures. It's small in there, so it does get loud. The food was good. We had the "GoodFellas" 12" pie and added sausage. The sausage was a little on the bland side, but the mozzarella and tomatoes made up for it. That Crust was THIN! I don't know how they would load up the toppings, but we managed. Our waitress was great she was on top of it. However, it took almost 45 minutes for us to get our single small pie. Again, the waitress kept giving updates and apologized several times. We were there on Friday night at 7, but 45 minutes wait for a pie seemed excessive. We will go back to Mulberry Street Pizza it was a good experience for a first-time visit.

Typical bar/restaurant with rustic decor and limited seating. Pizzas are typical New Haven style. The specialty pizzas are unique and tasty. We ordered 3 large, with two of them half-n-half. The waitress made a mistake on one. So, although we agreed to eat it rather than wait for the correct one, it wasn't what we wanted. Not saying it wasn't good, just not what we wanted. No harm, no foul.

amazing time! amazing food. amazing service. the food was phenomenal, new york style pizza. i’m convinced they have a fellow new yorker in the kitchen because their classic margarita pizza was SO authentic. the service was great, kind, helpful, attentive. wait time was super short and we had three pizzas and a burger in our party. lovely atmosphere and seasonal beverages. 11/10. We will definitely be coming back here.